|07-16-2018, 02:31 PM||#1|
Join Date: Oct 2017
2007 Aura XR (3.6L) - A/C Not working
I have a 2007 Aura XR (3.6L) and the A/C stopped working all of a sudden few weeks ago. However the previous day evening, it was putting good cold air.
I took it to Goodyear Auto care and did their A/C performance check and they said the compressor, condenser and expansion valve need to be changed and gave the quote (total of $1,449.75) for the following:
Compressor $ 685.10
Condenser $ 516.00
Expansion Valve $ 188.65
Evac-Recharge $ 60.00
I want to check with another place and took it to Firestone Auto care. They did their A/C performance check and
Cap and Valve Kit $ 27.99 (Part # 801797: A/C Valve Core and Cap Kit)
Labor $ 31.80
Total $ 59.79
R134A Per Ounce $ 2.50
R134A Per Pound $ 40.00
A/C System Dye $ 10.00
A/C Service $ 79.99
Net Total $192.28
The diagnosis and assessment is totally different from these two shops. Also the cost for the parts they quoted are available in AutoZone and other store for one-third of the price.
Can "A/C System Valve Core and Cap Kit" cause A/C stop working?
What should I do? Please advise and/or share your thoughts.
Thanks in Advance.
|SaturnFans.com Sponsored Links|
|07-16-2018, 03:04 PM||#2|
Join Date: Jun 2008
Location: Northboro, MA
2008 AURA XR
Re: 2007 Aura XR (3.6L) - A/C Not working
I would lean towards the firestone result. I have a 2008 that stopped working last year after 9 years. I used one of the self chargers with the gauge to determine that it was low on refrigerant and then added a small can. That got the compressor to kick on and its been working since, so it could be a very slow leak in the fill valve I suppose. Unless you have a lot of miles I would be suspect about the compressor going. The compressor is designed to stop working when the pressure (refrigerant) is low to prevent damage.
|07-16-2018, 07:14 PM||#3|
Join Date: Jan 2006
2003 L-Series 3.0L Sedan
Re: 2007 Aura XR (3.6L) - A/C Not working
If you never experienced deliberate gouging, lies, dishonesty, unethical and other words to describe quite possibly two divergent businesses, welcome to reality. Yes, you can find parts at discount prices but businesses mark up parts for several reasons; storage, handling, paying for expertise when repairing something, and the most important business priority - making a profit to stay in business or fold. We pay not only for repairs but for the expertise that goes into repairs. Labor is not cheap and adds to repair costs. Both estimates may be correct. The difficulty in determining why a large disparity in estimates may be due to unfamiliarity with vehicle ac systems to question why major parts are needed as opposed to the lower estimate possibly based on an honest assessment.
Did both places spend time assessing your system and then going over it with you with explanations? One may be completely gouging you to empty your wallet with lies while the other may be an honest business with everything to gain by replacing only parts that are needed in return for a successful repair and possible future visits for other repairs.
*A 30lb canister of r134a costs $96 - 0.20 cents per ounce
*A 12oz can of r134a costs $5 - 0.42 cents an ounce
Prices found are assuming a person knows what to do with refrigerant and can service vehicle ac systems. I didn't include the costs for refrigeration gauges, hoses, electric vacuum pump, and miscellaneous items for diy repairs. Knowledge of refrigeration cots money to learn, practice repairs, and having certification with an entity like ASE to provide professional services. Expertise costs money when relying on professional services.
|Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)|
|Thread||Thread Starter||Forum||Replies||Last Post|
|2007 Aura trunk release not working||pjm0322||Aura General||15||01-25-2017 01:25 PM|
|Sunroof not working in 2007 ion 3||Just.dre88||Ion Tech||4||04-15-2016 07:34 PM|
|saturn aura 2007 keyless remote not working||ole||Aura General||3||03-16-2014 01:27 PM|
|2007 Aura XR vs 2007 Passat 3.6 VR6||Seasoned||Aura General||5||12-09-2006 04:12 PM|
|2007 Aura XR vs 2007 2.0T passat sedan, which to buy?||fantarain||Aura General||43||11-26-2006 12:39 PM|