SaturnFans.com Forums

SaturnFans.com Forums (http://www.saturnfans.com/forums/index.php)
-   L-Series Tech (http://www.saturnfans.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=40)
-   -   2005 L300 crank but no start (http://www.saturnfans.com/forums/showthread.php?t=223615)

05Saturn l300 09-14-2016 05:57 AM

2005 L300 crank but no start
 
Hey guys I have a 05 Saturn l300, recently it will crank over strong and takes a long time to fire, like 10 10 second tries. As soon as it fires it's good until it sits for more than 6 hours. The only code it reads is p0421. Which it has for 2 years. I replaced the coolant temp sensor and fuel filter and it still starts hard for the first start of the day. Any ideas? Thanks

soulsurvives 09-14-2016 06:18 AM

Re: 2005 L300 crank but no start
 
How many miles are on it? Plugs are due at 100k...I would also run seafoam and some good fuel system cleaner thru it.

05Saturn l300 09-14-2016 06:49 AM

Re: 2005 L300 crank but no start
 
[QUOTE=soulsurvives;2210903]How many miles are on it? Plugs are due at 100k...I would also run seafoam and some good fuel system cleaner thru it.[/QUOTE]

120k it just rolled, I have not done plugs yet. Will it start hard but then run smooth??

pierrot 09-14-2016 11:02 AM

Re: 2005 L300 crank but no start
 
[QUOTE=05Saturn l300;2210907]120k it just rolled, I have not done plugs yet. Will it start hard but then run smooth??[/QUOTE]
Worn plugs will result in hard starting. Whether or not the engine would be smooth running I cannot say for certain, but it is possible. In either case it's likely to result in poorer burning of fuel.

From the 2000 Saturn L81 FSM
"[B]P0421 or P0422[/B]: WARM UP CATALYST LOW EFFICIENCY BANK 1

The catalyst is used to control emission content. Although the catalyst is active as soon as exhaust gas is passed through it, this diagnostic will not run until the front and rear oxygen sensors are both in closed loop. The oxygen storing capability of the catalyst is monitored by viewing the rear oxygen sensor's response to an oscillating air-fuel ratio. The ECM computes how a near-failure catalyst would cause a rear oxygen sensor to react to an oscillating air-fuel ratio. These values are compared with the actual rear oxygen sensor response. If the actual response is similar to the near failure catalyst computed values, this code will set.

[B]DTC PARAMETERS[/B]

DTC P0421 and P0422 will set when:
- Closed loop is enabled
- Engine speed is between 1400 and 2000 rpm
- Engine load is between 20% and 45%
- Catalyst temperature greater than 350 degrees C (662 degrees F)
- No front or rear oxygen sensor, misfire, MAF, TP, purge solenoids codes set

[B]DIAGNOSTIC AIDS[/B]

Once set, this code should remain active. Under certain driving conditions the catalyst monitor test may pass. This condition may occur if driving the vehicle at highway speeds (high air flow), but if this code is set and there are no exhaust leaks, the converter should be replaced. If a misfire code is detected, the catalyst monitor test will not run. Be sure to correct a misfire condition before replacing the converter.

Possible causes:
- Exhaust system leak between front and rear sensors, or rear sensor leaking.
- Catalyst deteriorated due to excessive time operating vehicle with a damaging misfire.
- Contamination of converter due to incorrect sealant, fuel or fuel additive."

It would be wise to replace the spark plugs as you're already aware that they've gone beyond the factory recommended replacement interval. I suspect, however, that their replacement will not correct this issue (I'd be happy to be wrong!). Nevertheless, the only way to know if any benefit is derived is to replace them before attempting to correct this DTC.

05Saturn l300 09-14-2016 11:52 AM

Re: 2005 L300 crank but no start
 
[QUOTE=pierrot;2210928]Worn plugs will result in hard starting. Whether or not the engine would be smooth running I cannot say for certain, but it is possible. In either case it's likely to result in poorer burning of fuel.

From the 2000 Saturn L81 FSM
"[B]P0421 or P0422[/B]: WARM UP CATALYST LOW EFFICIENCY BANK 1

The catalyst is used to control emission content. Although the catalyst is active as soon as exhaust gas is passed through it, this diagnostic will not run until the front and rear oxygen sensors are both in closed loop. The oxygen storing capability of the catalyst is monitored by viewing the rear oxygen sensor's response to an oscillating air-fuel ratio. The ECM computes how a near-failure catalyst would cause a rear oxygen sensor to react to an oscillating air-fuel ratio. These values are compared with the actual rear oxygen sensor response. If the actual response is similar to the near failure catalyst computed values, this code will set.

[B]DTC PARAMETERS[/B]

DTC P0421 and P0422 will set when:
- Closed loop is enabled
- Engine speed is between 1400 and 2000 rpm
- Engine load is between 20% and 45%
- Catalyst temperature greater than 350 degrees C (662 degrees F)
- No front or rear oxygen sensor, misfire, MAF, TP, purge solenoids codes set

[B]DIAGNOSTIC AIDS[/B]

Once set, this code should remain active. Under certain driving conditions the catalyst monitor test may pass. This condition may occur if driving the vehicle at highway speeds (high air flow), but if this code is set and there are no exhaust leaks, the converter should be replaced. If a misfire code is detected, the catalyst monitor test will not run. Be sure to correct a misfire condition before replacing the converter.

Possible causes:
- Exhaust system leak between front and rear sensors, or rear sensor leaking.
- Catalyst deteriorated due to excessive time operating vehicle with a damaging misfire.
- Contamination of converter due to incorrect sealant, fuel or fuel additive."

It would be wise to replace the spark plugs as you're already aware that they've gone beyond the factory recommended replacement interval. I suspect, however, that their replacement will not correct this issue (I'd be happy to be wrong!). Nevertheless, the only way to know if any benefit is derived is to replace them before attempting to correct this DTC.[/QUOTE]


Ok thank you plugs are going in tonight, if that doesn't correct it I guess I'll be throwing a new O2 sensor or 2 at it.

fdryer 09-14-2016 11:55 AM

Re: 2005 L300 crank but no start
 
While spark plugs may be fine, due to ideal use of platinum electrodes for long term reliability, it's just wise to replace them. They're probably not worn but the number of heat cycles may degrade them and a reason to replace them every 100k miles. The same goes for fuel filter replacement. With difficulty in startups, this problem can be either ignition or fuel related. One way to monitor one of these two would be using a fuel pressure gauge connected to the fuel rail test port. Autozone may have pressure gauges to loan. Expect 40-55 psi when ignition is turned on without starting and remain in range with engine running. Fuel filter replacement is recommended every 100k miles.

The mystery P0421 code may or may not contribute to hard starting. A partially blocked pre-cat, between engine and firewall, may trigger the error code. While blocking half the exhaust system shouldn't affect engine starting, anything is possible in real world operating conditions. The difficulty in determining a damaged pre-cat requires removal for examination or connecting a pressure gauge to the front O2 port on each side to measure exhaust pressures - not something anyone wants to do.

One thing not discussed and brought up - is there a possibility of the maf sensor causing this problem? Removing it and spraying it with maf sensor cleaner may help.

05Saturn l300 09-14-2016 12:06 PM

Re: 2005 L300 crank but no start
 
[QUOTE=fdryer;2210934]While spark plugs may be fine, due to ideal use of platinum electrodes for long term reliability, it's just wise to replace them. They're probably not worn but the number of heat cycles may degrade them and a reason to replace them every 100k miles. The same goes for fuel filter replacement. With difficulty in startups, this problem can be either ignition or fuel related. One way to monitor one of these two would be using a fuel pressure gauge connected to the fuel rail test port. Autozone may have pressure gauges to loan. Expect 40-55 psi when ignition is turned on without starting and remain in range with engine running. Fuel filter replacement is recommended every 100k miles.

The mystery P0421 code may or may not contribute to hard starting. A partially blocked pre-cat, between engine and firewall, may trigger the error code. While blocking half the exhaust system shouldn't affect engine starting, anything is possible in real world operating conditions. The difficulty in determining a damaged pre-cat requires removal for examination or connecting a pressure gauge to the front O2 port on each side to measure exhaust pressures - not something anyone wants to do.

One thing not discussed and brought up - is there a possibility of the maf sensor causing this problem? Removing it and spraying it with maf sensor cleaner may help.[/QUOTE]


Ok, thank you! I will clean that also. I'll post my results

pierrot 09-14-2016 01:42 PM

Re: 2005 L300 crank but no start
 
[QUOTE=05Saturn l300;2210933]......I guess I'll be throwing a new O2 sensor or 2 at it.[/QUOTE]I think that replacing an O2 sensor presently is an unwarranted course of action. The DTC PARAMETERS states, in part, that the

"DTC P0421 and P0422 will set when:
- [U][B][COLOR="red"]No front or rear oxygen sensor[/COLOR][/B][/U], misfire, MAF, TP, purge solenoids [B][U][COLOR="red"]codes set[/COLOR][/U][/B]

[B][I][COLOR="blue"]fdryer[/COLOR][/I][/B]'s advice to clean the MAF sensor is sound. If there is no improvement then, based upon the FSM information, I would look to an exhaust leak or failed catalytic converter. You said that this code has been present for two years. What would you estimate the mileage to have been when the DTC was set?

An unrelated question came to mind with your car since the spark plugs are very late in being replaced. [I]Has the timing belt been replaced?[/I] That should've been replaced at 100K miles as well.

s3nfo 09-15-2016 08:39 AM

Re: 2005 L300 crank but no start
 
Crank but no start is usually the Crank Position Sensor (CPS)

05Saturn l300 09-20-2016 08:30 PM

Re: 2005 L300 crank but no start
 
[QUOTE=s3nfo;2211025]Crank but no start is usually the Crank Position Sensor (CPS)[/QUOTE]


Ok guys reporting back, changed plugs, and did fuel pressure test. Fuel pump was not turning on all the time, replaced the pump, still doesn't turn on every time not sure why not yet.

pierrot 09-20-2016 11:01 PM

Re: 2005 L300 crank but no start
 
[QUOTE=05Saturn l300;2211650]......changed plugs, and did fuel pressure test. Fuel pump was not turning on all the time, replaced the pump, still doesn't turn on every time not sure why not yet.[/QUOTE]Ouch! That's a difficult result to have after all of the work it takes to replace a fuel pump. :(

[QUOTE=s3nfo;2211025]Crank but no start is usually the Crank Position Sensor (CPS)[/QUOTE]Based on the information above provided by the [B][I]05Saturn l300[/I][/B] I tend to agree with [B][I]s3nfo[/I][/B] in this instance. You may be experiencing a failing crankshaft position sensor. When that part is in a state of diminshed capacity, most often it will not generate a DTC even while it causes varying degrees and types of trouble. Look up threads in the L Series Forums about that sensor and you may find some commonality between your situation and experiences had by others.

Unrelated to the no start problem: have you cleaned the MAF sensor yet?

05Saturn l300 09-21-2016 05:59 AM

Re: 2005 L300 crank but no start
 
[QUOTE=pierrot;2211664]Ouch! That's a difficult result to have after all of the work it takes to replace a fuel pump. :(

Based on the information above provided by the [B][I]05Saturn l300[/I][/B] I tend to agree with [B][I]s3nfo[/I][/B] in this instance. You may be experiencing a failing crankshaft position sensor. When that part is in a state of diminshed capacity, most often it will not generate a DTC even while it causes varying degrees and types of trouble. Look up threads in the L Series Forums about that sensor and you may find some commonality between your situation and experiences had by others.

Unrelated to the no start problem: have you cleaned the MAF sensor yet?[/QUOTE]

Yes, MAF has been cleaned. Will the crank sensor cause the fuel pump to not kick on? The crank sensor was replaced about 9 months ago.

fdryer 09-21-2016 07:15 AM

Re: 2005 L300 crank but no start
 
Personally, I can state a faulty crank sensor will prevent; fuel pump operation during starting, spark and injector pulses. A very good method for troubleshooting would be spraying starting fluid into the throttle. It's difficult to perform a spark test on our V6 engines and some info can be learned by depressing the fuel test valve on the fuel rail over the engine. The fuel pump will run for two seconds at ignition ON time, enough to generate pressure to spray fuel from the test valve. If you have fuel spray from the test valve pump is working. However, this doesn't tell anyone if injectors operating. Other cars can verify injector or spark operation by removing spark plugs and checking for fuel after several failed starting attempts when fuel is injected at every startup. A lack of fuel and spark points to a faulty crank sensor (next to the oil filter housing). Spraying starting fluid into your engine should result in starting up under normal circumstances. Be sure to check for blown fuses.

05Saturn l300 09-29-2016 09:36 PM

Re: 2005 L300 crank but no start
 
[QUOTE=fdryer;2211681]Personally, I can state a faulty crank sensor will prevent; fuel pump operation during starting, spark and injector pulses. A very good method for troubleshooting would be spraying starting fluid into the throttle. It's difficult to perform a spark test on our V6 engines and some info can be learned by depressing the fuel test valve on the fuel rail over the engine. The fuel pump will run for two seconds at ignition ON time, enough to generate pressure to spray fuel from the test valve. If you have fuel spray from the test valve pump is working. However, this doesn't tell anyone if injectors operating. Other cars can verify injector or spark operation by removing spark plugs and checking for fuel after several failed starting attempts when fuel is injected at every startup. A lack of fuel and spark points to a faulty crank sensor (next to the oil filter housing). Spraying starting fluid into your engine should result in starting up under normal circumstances. Be sure to check for blown fuses.[/QUOTE]

Just an update for all.. Replaced fuel pump, and filter, also changed out plugs, coolant temp sensor and cleaned mass air flow sensor. Car runs good. But 2 times in the last 1,000 miles the fuel pump does not kick on with the key and I do not understand why so any insite on that would be great. I did notice the small metal line going up towards the fuel cap(breather?) was pretty rusty. I'm not sure if that would cause this issues once in a while?

fdryer 09-29-2016 11:26 PM

Re: 2005 L300 crank but no start
 
1-Are you describing the fuel fill pipe with a second smaller diameter pipe? [url]http://www.saturnfans.com/forums/showthread.php?t=222339[/url] While a severely corroded vent tube won't affect fuel pump operation, it will generate an emission error code, P0455 or P0442. A few members have made repairs, replacing this fuel filler assembly from either salvage yards in good condition or buying new.

2-The two second fuel pump cycle at ignition ON time will not cycle if the ignition key is repeatedly turned on, off and back on. A timer delays pump operation so a waiting period of about 15-30 seconds is needed before trying to cycle the pump again. What's more important is not so much detecting pump operation with key on but having the pump run while starting. The best way to know is connecting a fuel pressure gauge to see instantaneous pressure at key on time. If you are doubtful about the pump running, cycle ignition off for 30 seconds before cycling ignition on again. Be aware that pressure doesn't bleed off immediately after ignition is turned on.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 07:44 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.9
Copyright ©2000 - 2017, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
SaturnFans.com. The Saturn Enthusiasts Site.